Will Manifold implement hierarchical groups and subgroups by the end of 2024?
➕
Plus
25
Ṁ5987
Jan 1
95%
chance

An example of what I'm imagining would be like if markets added to US Politics or UK Politics also showed up in Politics. Further, markets added to, say, California Politics would show up in US Politics and Politics. In other words, these hierarchies would be arbitrarily deep. Another interpretation of this concept might be if the "Communities" featured on the Groups page were themselves groups that users could create and manage like any other group.

This market resolves "YES" if anything resembling this concept exists by the end of 2024. Otherwise, this market resolves "NO" instead.

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:
bought Ṁ250 YES

@cos I think this resolves YES. Sinclair implemented this a few weeks ago. Groups have "subtopics", so there's a nested structure.

this isn't quite the maximalist version described in the description. but the description to me seems pretty clear—it outlines two potential versions of this, and says

This market resolves "YES" if anything resembling this concept exists by the end of 2024. Otherwise, this market resolves "NO" instead.

This is not exactly the example described in the description, but it's certain'y "anything resembling this concept". ("subtopics" had been requested for a while)

bought Ṁ100 YES from 84% to 85%
sold Ṁ510 YES

@Ziddletwix i'll let you buy more yes if you want to but I agree

@Bayesian you’re welcome to buy the rest I think this is straightforward but I require a large risk premium when dealing with subjective resolutions (which I dislike getting bogged down in)

bought Ṁ250 YES

@Ziddletwix sounds good, I'll argue on your behalf if there is need for someone to get bogged down into this... (I don't mind subjective resolutions personally)

@Ziddletwix @mods very inactive creator—can someone rule on/resolve this one?

This is interesting. Voting YES because this seems like a logical feature to have.
Although I am curious to see how it might be implemented. Could a group belong to two or more parent groups? probably. Would want to make sure though that you couldn't end up with a cyclical recursion relationship between groups. So there might need to be a test for loops or some other validation to enforce one direction hierarchy.

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules