Are civilians in Gaza culpable for the actions of Hamas?
50
Never closes
Yes
No
This question is managed and resolved by Manifold.
Get
1,000
and3.00
Sort by:
Instability invites the nastiest folks to take charge. When a governing structure lacks legitimacy, it has to use disproportionate violence to stave off anyone else who wants to take charge.
This isn't a moral defence of Hamas' attrocities. Saying asbestos cause cancer is not defending the morality of cancer; it is saying that if you want to avoid cancer you should avoid asbestos. Until the Palestinians have a stable government it should be expected that the most radical segments of the population will inflict violence. The median Palestinian is innocent, unless you think it was their fault for being born in the wrong place.
Related questions
Related questions
Will Israel be held responsible for its war crimes is Gaza?
25% chance
After 6 months without open warfare, who will be in control of Gaza?
Did Israel execute unarmed Gazans on December 19th for no good reason?
45% chance
Will Israel commit war crimes by cutting off food/water, electricity, and fuel to the Gaza Strip?
78% chance
Will the ICJ determine that Israel committed war crimes in Gaza?
85% chance
After the Israel-Hamas war is over, would the average Israeli believe it was a mistake?
10% chance
Who is more responsible for the deaths of civilians in Gaza?
POLL
why war in Gaza
Ṁ250 bounty
Who is more responsible for the recent outbreak of violence between Israel and Hamas?
POLL
How many Gazan civilians must die before IDF/Israel should face punitive consequences from the international community?
POLL